A Hong Kong doctor accused of fraudulently issuing around 3,700 Covid-19 vaccine exemption certificates during the pandemic has been found guilty of accessing a computer with dishonest intent.
BioNTech Covid vaccine. Photo: BioNTech.Tai Kong-shing received his verdict at the District Court on Friday after pleading not guilty. He was also found guilty of money laundering.
A volunteer at the clinic, Kriselle Young, was also found guilty of accessing a computer with dishonest intent.
According to the prosecution, the pair conspired to defraud the Health Bureau between February and September 2022 by dishonestly claiming that some patients were medically unfit to receive the Covid-19 vaccine.
Tai handed out 3,751 vaccine exemptions, charging between HK$1,000 and HK$4,000 each.
During the Covid-19 pandemic, members of the public were required to meet vaccination requirements to access restaurants, gyms and other specified premises.
District Court in Wan Chai. File photo: HKFP.Delivering the verdict, Judge Ernest Lin said the clinic made use of the “unreasonable, unscientific fears” of “selfish” members of the public for commercial gain.
He said Tai, as a doctor, had sufficient medical knowledge to understand the Hospital Authority’s guidelines. Yet he gave out vaccine exemptions simply because his patients were paying him, rather than after assessing their medical conditions.
Lin said that Young was not a trained medical practitioner, but that she introduced patients to the clinic and allocated work to the nurses. She knowingly assisted Tai in inputting false information, the judge added.
Police sting operationDuring an undercover operation that led to the pair’s arrest, three police officers disguised themselves as patients and visited Tai’s clinic to request Covid-19 vaccine exemptions, saying they were afraid to get the jab.
Tai issued the exemptions, including one for an officer’s son who was not at the appointment.
A woman scans her LeaveHomeSafe app outside a shopping mall. Photo: GovHK.Tai testified during the trial that he did not blindly give out exemptions to patients, saying they had suffered from gastritis, chest pain, asthma and other conditions that made them unfit for the vaccine.
Young also testified, saying that she was a volunteer at the clinic and that she trusted Tai’s judgement. She said she never thought that he had abused the issuing of exemption certificates.
When asked by the prosecution about a WhatsApp message she had sent to a patient reading “don’t worry, [it’ll] definitely be issued,” Young denied reassuring the patient that they would be able to obtain an exemption certificate, saying instead that she was comforting them.