MADISON, WISCONSIN - NOVEMBER 10: Owen Foxwell #15 talks with Head Coach Greg Gard of the Wisconsin Badgers during the second half of the game against the Fairfield Stags at Kohl Center on November 10, 2026 in Madison, Wisconsin. (Photo by John Fisher/Getty Images) | Getty Images

I waited longer than normal to do this piece because the 2026-27 Wisconsin Badgers carried more uncertainty than usual coming into the season, and I’m glad that I did. The first three weeks of the campaign have been both illuminating and disturbing.

One big question coming in was whether or not Wisconsin would effectively replace two premium scorers, John Blackwell and Nick Boyd. We all saw an offensive drop-off on the horizon, but how steep it would be was far from certain.

There were also associated worries about the lack of a slasher, along with spooky point guard depth. And, of course, fitting the pieces together has always been a puzzle for Greg Gard, who has generally completed it deftly in recent years. Winning the lottery three consecutive transfer portal cycles certainly helped matters.

But as we inch toward December, it is clear that this version of the Badgers is flawed and, after losing Jack Janicki to what could be a long-term injury, is now down a major rotational player. Other issues have been a lack of consistent scoring and an oddly passive start from pre-season All-Big Ten senior Nolan Winter, who is very talented but has, at times, looked disinterested on his way to a tepid 8.0 points per game so far, due to a lack of shooting volume.

And while they have had nice moments, it’s hard to be overly excited about portal headliner Eian Elmer or new point guard Owen Foxwell. Both have offered flashes, especially Foxwell, but it hasn’t been nearly enough. Making matters worse, transfer big man Victory Onuetu has looked, at times, unplayable.

Adding to all this, nobody appears so far to be better than they were in 2026-27, and team cohesion seems broken, as best evidenced by a forgettable two games at the Baha Mar Championship, where the Badgers were outplayed by two decent but not special teams in Seton Hall and Murray State, never looking comfortable and shooting awfully.

So, the quick take is that things are not good for Gard’s team and there is a legitimate reason to worry about an awful season. But Gard is a very good coach, and I suspect he will have some fixes to raise the squad’s suddenly troubling floor. However, nothing is a given.

After seeing the first stretch of games for Wisconsin, here are my Best Case, Worst Case, and Most Likely scenarios for the 4-2 Badgers the rest of the way.

Best Case

I’ll admit right here at the outset that I’m relying as much on track record and projectables, including Winter rounding into form and Foxwell/Elmer settling in under the brighter lights in Madison, as anything else. But a reversion to the mean is a tough thing to use as the basis of an optimistic projection.

It’s possible to imagine the rotation solidifying, perhaps with more Jackson Ball, who is raw but clearly talented, and the parts we’ve all seen do good things before, like Austin Rapp and Braeden Carrington, stepping up.

It’s not crazy to believe Gard settles things down and forges a solid, tough Big Ten team. But one with a high upside like last year’s seems all but impossible.

Prediction: 19-13, No. 10 seed in NCAA Tournament

Worst Case

This one pains me to write but I need to be real here.

Even presuming health, early returns showing a team full of role players and secondary scorers, with no rim challenging slashers and some periodically questionable defensive and rebounding lapses, spells deep trouble vs the Big Ten.

While there are still some bright spots, especially at home, more often than not this team gets chewed up and spit out by better teams, leading to Greg Gard’s first losing season in a decade and a renaissance year for the Fire Gard Army.

Prediction: 12-20, no postseason.

Most Likely Case

I hope that I’m ultimately humbled by this prediction, but I’m finding an unusually difficult time being optimistic about this team based off early returns. It simply isn’t as good as recent squads and I’m not going to pretend this isn’t the case just because I hold the coach in high regard.

Yes, I see improvement for Winter and some of the rest going forward, and as noted, Ball is an intriguing young talent. But not having a reliable scorer like Blackwell will simply cap this team’s ceiling. There’s no way to sugar coat it.

There will be several nice moments and, I’m sure, an upset or two, but at this point it is looking like the worst Badger team in a decade and that one had All-Big Ten star Ethan Happ. This season will almost certainly be Gard’s biggest challenge since taking over for Bo Ryan in late 2015 and even an expanded NCAA Tournament looks unlikely.

Prediction: 16-16, NIT.